May is National Foster Care Month. Foster care is often the only possible choice for children who face almost unthinkably bad conditions when living at home. Even so, a worthwhile goal for foster care is, when possible, to make it more rare and more brief.

A reason to aim for rarer and briefer is, children in the foster care system are particularly vulnerable to being sex trafficked. The National Center for Missing & Exploited Children(NCMEC) has some sobering statistics on this.

In 2016, one in six of the more than 26,300 cases of children who were reported to NCMEC as runaways were likely victims of child sex trafficking. The anti-trafficking organization,Polaris says that of those who were likely victims of sex-trafficking, more than 85% were in the care of social services or foster care when they ran away.

Foster Care Is a Balancing Act

Removing a child from his or her home is a balancing act between the terrible conditions at home, and the possibility of increasing the child’s vulnerability to trafficking.

By the time Child Protective Services (CPS) is called in, there may be drug use, physical injury, sexual abuse or exploitation. There may also be an act or failure to act that presents an imminent risk of serious harm to the child.

When a situation has gotten that bad, surely it makes sense for society to step in and remove a child from a dangerous situation. And yet, there are other considerations.

Specifically, before removing children from a bad situation, Anne Basham, CEO of Anti-Trafficking International, would like to see child-welfare agencies do more to make it possible for the child to stay with his or her parent or parents. This would include more focus on giving the parent training or resources in how to make the child’s environment safer.

For example, Basham recommends the following:

• Provide greater funding for interventions in the family before removal of a child is necessary.
• Work to rehabilitate the family, such as helping a parent fill out forms for SNAP or other forms of assistance
• If a child is truant, find the reason why and address the problem.

In many situations, such interventions would not be an option. However, one of Basham’s major concerns is that taking children from their homes may leave children with scars that increase their vulnerability to traffickers.

“The trauma of being ripped from their homes,” she points out, “can result in scars that may be worse than the original traumas they were subjected to in their homes.”