Unpacking criminalization of sex work and how it keeps sex workers vulnerable
New research from Decrim Now reveals that poverty, job insecurity, and the rising cost of living are the main reasons people enter sex work. As living expenses outpace wages, more people are turning to sex work for survival.
In the UK, sex work exists in a grey area: selling sex is legal, but most related activities are criminalized. This partial criminalization deters workers from reporting violence or exploitation out of fear of arrest, increasing their vulnerability.
“You cannot criminalize people out of poverty”
When Sofia, a 28-year-old social care worker from London, saw her rent rise by £300 while her wages stagnated, she turned to her credit card to get by—until debt spiralled out of control. She told the Big Issue that,
“The only reason I made the choice to do sex work was because of structural and societal issues—wages haven’t risen with inflation, and no rental caps have been set.”
According to Decrim Now’s survey of 172 sex workers, 76% entered the industry due to financial need, and 77% live with a disability or long-term health condition. “Sex work is being increasingly turned to as a way to fill in the gaps left by terrible wages, unaffordable childcare, or cuts to disability benefits,” said Audre Whorne from Decrim Now.
Under current UK laws, even basic safety measures can be illegal.
“If a friend and I decided to work together in a shared flat so that we can look out for each other, that flat would be classed as a brothel,” explained another worker, Tanya.
Whorne warns that criminalization traps workers in poverty. Often, police will fine workers, which only contributes to the cycle of debt, sex work, and risk of arrest.
Still, according to Whorne, there has been a “concerted effort” from some politicians, to implement the Nordic Model. This model criminalizes the person who purchases sex in efforts to end the demand for sex work, and by effect, prevent people from entering into sex work. However, according to Whorne:
In every country the Nordic Model has been implemented in, it has failed to prevent people from, nor decrease the amount of people, entering sex work. This is because the Nordic Model fundamentally fails to understand why people enter sex work, people don’t start sex work due to demand but because of poverty. The only thing the Nordic Model is evidenced to be successful in is putting sex workers at greater risk of arrest, poverty, violence and death.”